26 La. Ann. 504

No. 3481.

James J. O’Hara v. John Krantz.

The plaintiff’s contract with the city of 2>Tew Orleans did not embrace the work for which payment is sought in this suit, and the defendant was making the improvement himself with the assent of the city authorities, when he was interfered with by the plaintiff officiously completing the work defendant had begun, in despite of his opposition.

There may be hardship involved in the result which enriches the proprietor at the plaintiffs expense, but, however it mayor should recommend itself to the conscience of the proprietor, it is a hardship of the plaintiffs own seeking, which can not be judicially remedied.

Appeal from the Seventh District Court, parish of Orleans. Col-lens, J.

Jury trial. Mornor & Benedict, for plaintiff and appellee. J. A. & V. J, Hosier, for defendant and appellant.

Ltjdeling, C. J.

This is an action for $637 49, the alleged price claimed for the construction of a brick banquette in front of defendant’s property. The plaintiff’s contract with the city did not embrace this work, and the defendant was making the improvement himself, with the assent of the city authorities, when he was interfered with by the plaintiff officiously completing the work defendant had begun, in-despite of his opposition.

There may be hardship involved in the result which enriches the proprietor at the plaintiff’s expense, but it is a hardship, which, however it may or should recommend itself to the conscience of the proprietor, can not judicially countervail the higher consideration of public policy. The hardship is of the plaintiff’s own making. 10 An. 11.

It is therefore ordered and adjudged that the verdict of the jury be set aside; that the judgment of the lower court be annulled, and that there be judgment in favor of the defendant, rejecting the plaintiff’s demands, with costs.

O'Hara v. Krantz
26 La. Ann. 504

Case Details

Name
O'Hara v. Krantz
Decision Date
May 1, 1874
Citations

26 La. Ann. 504

Jurisdiction
Louisiana

References

Referencing

Nothing yet... Still searching!

Referenced By

Nothing yet... Still searching!