681 So. 2d 732

TRANSPORTATION CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant, v. SUNCOAST RECYCLING AND TRANSFER, INC., Through David IRWIN, Trustee; David Irwin, Individually; Richard E. Pracel; Robert Indermuehle and Lillian Indermuehle, Individually; and Government Employees Insurance Company, Appellees.

No. 95-02186.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Second District.

May 29, 1996.

*733Arthur J. England, Jr., Elliot H. Scherker and John G. Crabtree of Greenberg, Traurig, Hoffman, Lipoff, Rosen & Quental, P.A., Miami, and Robert D. Mosés of Wiederhold, Moses, Bulfin & Rubin, P.A., West Palm Beach, for Appellant.

Guy N. Perenich and James L. O’Leary, II, of Perenich, Avril, Perenich, Avril & Caul-field, Clearwater, for Appellees Indermuehle.

No appearance for Appellees Suncoast Recycling and Transfer, Inc.; Irwin; Pracel; and Government Employees Insurance Company.

THREADGILL, Chief Judge.

Transportation Casualty Insurance Company (TCI) appeals a final judgment directing a verdict in favor of Suncoast Recycling and Transfer, Inc., and the other appellees. We reverse on the ground that the trial court lost jurisdiction when TCI filed a notice of voluntary dismissal.

Angel Indermeuhle was killed in an accident involving a Suncoast truck driven by its employee Richard E. Pracel. Her estate sued Suncoast, the driver, and Suncoast’s owner David Irwin for negligence. In a complaint for declaratory judgment, Suncoast’s insurer TCI contended that the truck was not covered by insurance because Pracel was not an approved driver at the time of the accident.

A non-jury trial began in the declaratory judgment action. After TCI had rested, the appellees moved for an involuntary dismissal. The trial court reserved ruling, and the appellees proceeded with their defense. During the appellees’ case, TCI announced it was voluntarily dismissing the declaratory action. The appellees objected on the ground that the dismissal was untimely because TCI had already rested. The trial court agreed and the trial continued. When the appellees had rested, they renewed their motion for an involuntary dismissal which the trial court then granted. TCI appealed.

TCI contends and we agree that the trial court erred in ruling that the voluntary dismissal was untimely. The trial court construed Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.420(a)1 to require a plaintiff to enter a voluntary dismissal before resting its case. On the contrary, a plaintiff may enter a voluntary dismissal at any time before the case is submitted to the trier of fact for a determination. Randle-Eastern Ambulance Service, Inc. v. Vasta, 360 So.2d 68 (Fla.1978); Fears v. Lunsford, 314 So.2d 578 (Fla.1975).

We therefore reverse the order denying the notice of voluntary dismissal. We need not address the issue of the directed verdict entered in favor of the appellees at the conclusion of the trial.

Reversed.

DANAHY and FRANK, JJ., concur.

Transportation Casualty Insurance Co. v. Suncoast Recycling & Transfer, Inc. ex rel. Irwin
681 So. 2d 732

Case Details

Name
Transportation Casualty Insurance Co. v. Suncoast Recycling & Transfer, Inc. ex rel. Irwin
Decision Date
May 29, 1996
Citations

681 So. 2d 732

Jurisdiction
Florida

References

Referencing

Nothing yet... Still searching!

Referenced By

Nothing yet... Still searching!