119 Ind. 109

No. 13,912.

Johnson v. Conklin.

Pleading. — Amendment.— Waiver of Exceptions.- — Where a defendant, after a demurrer has been sustained to his answer, obtains leave to amend, and files another answer, he thereby waives the exceptions taken on the original pleading.

Pbomissoby Note. — Beal Party in Interest. — Estoppel.—The maker of a promissory note is estopped from showing that the payee was not the real party in interest at the time the note was executed.

From the Martin Circuit Court.

J. T. Rogers, for appellant.

E. Moser and H. Q. Houghton, for appellee.

*110Filed May 17, 1889.

Elliott, C. J. —

The plaintiff, Maria Conklin, brought this action to recover the amount evidenced by a promissory note executed to her as payee by the appellant. The trial court sustained demurrers to several paragraphs of the answer filed by the appellant, and he thereupon asked and obtained leave to amend. He subsequently filed several paragraphs of answer, to which the plaintiff replied. He here complains of the ruling on the demurrers to the original answer. His complaint is unavailing. Prima facie, the answers last filed were amendments of the original .pleading, and that pleading went out of the case when the last answers were filed. By filing the answers after the leave to amend was obtained, the exceptions taken on the original pleading were waived. Hunter v. Pfeiffer, 108 Ind. 197.

But if we should consider the original answer as properly in the record, and the exceptions as available, it would not change the result, for the answer is bad. It seeks to show that the payee of the note was not the real party in interest at the time the note was executed, and this the maker of a promissory note is estopped from doing. Blacker v. Dunbar, 108 Ind. 217; Wells v. Sutton, 85 Ind. 70; Rogers v. Place, 29 Ind. 577; French, v. Blanchard, 16 Ind. 143.

Judgment affirmed, with ten per centum damages.

Johnson v. Conklin
119 Ind. 109

Case Details

Name
Johnson v. Conklin
Decision Date
May 17, 1889
Citations

119 Ind. 109

Jurisdiction
Indiana

References

Referencing

Nothing yet... Still searching!

Referenced By

Nothing yet... Still searching!