443 Mass. 1017

Dwayne M. Cruthird vs. Superior Court Department of the Trial Court for the County of Suffolk.

March 16, 2005.

Supreme Judicial Court,

The case was submitted on briefs.

Dwayne M. Cruthird, pro se.

Pierce O. Cray, Assistant Attorney General, for the defendant.

In his petition, Cruthird challenged the applicability of the so-called civil litigation anniversary fee statute, G. L. c. 262, § 4D,1 to cases that were commenced before the effective date of the statute. Cruthird (as a plaintiff) had at least two such cases pending in the Superior Court at the time he filed his petition, and in each case he had moved successfully in the Superior Court to have the fee waived when it was imposed. The single justice denied the G. L. c. 211, § 3, petition without a hearing.

To the extent that Cruthird sought to use his petition to obtain relief in his own two cases, the single justice correctly denied the petition because no relief was needed. The fees had already been waived in both cases by judges in the Superior Court. Insofar as Cruthird sought to use his petition to obtain a declaration that the anniversary fee statute was unconstitutional generally, and purports to pursue the present appeal on that basis, the matter is moot in light of the statute’s repeal.

So ordered.

Cruthird v. Superior Court Department
443 Mass. 1017

Case Details

Name
Cruthird v. Superior Court Department
Decision Date
Mar 16, 2005
Citations

443 Mass. 1017

Jurisdiction
Massachusetts

References

Referencing

Nothing yet... Still searching!

Referenced By

Nothing yet... Still searching!