82 Cal. 659

[No. 13377.

Department Two

January 31, 1890.]

JAMES A. WATERMAN, Appellant, v. F. M. BOLTINGHOUSE, Respondent.

PRINCIPAL AND AGENT — BROKERAGE — EXCLUSIVE RIGHT TO SELL REALTY — Sale by Principal —-Commissions. —An agent or broker to whom is given the exclusive right, for a certain period, to sell a tract of land belonging to another, cannot recover his commissions when the owner sells the land during this period, unless he has produced a purchaser ready and willing to buy on the terms specified in his contract of employment.

Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Fresno County.

The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.

Meux & Edwards, for Appellant.

E. C. Winchell, and Wharton & Short, for Respondent.

Thornton, J.

This is an action by plaintiff to recover commissions for an alleged sale of land. He never produced a purchaser ready and willing to buy on the terms of his employer, the defendant. He cannot, therefore, recover. (Dolan v. Scanlan, 57 Cal. 261; Moses v. Bierling, 31 N. Y. 462; Sibbald v. Bethlehem Iron Co., 83 N. Y. 378; 22 Am. Rep. 441.)

Here the plaintiff had the exclusive right to sell for a term ending January 1, 1889, and the defendant, during this period, himself effected a sale. Though the plaintiff had the right to sell, to the exclusion of his employer, still he cannot recover his commissions unless he has produced a purchaser ready and willing to buy as above stated. This is expressly held, and correctly held, in Moses v. Bierling, supra, which is a case similar to this.

The plaintiff argues this case as if it was a suit to recover damages for defendant’s breach of contract. The complaint does not set forth any such action, but one to recover the compensation agreed to be paid on a sale.

There is no error.

Judgment affirmed.

McFarland, J., and Sharpstein, J., concurred.

Waterman v. Boltinghouse
82 Cal. 659

Case Details

Name
Waterman v. Boltinghouse
Decision Date
Jan 31, 1890
Citations

82 Cal. 659

Jurisdiction
California

References

Referencing

Nothing yet... Still searching!

Referenced By

Nothing yet... Still searching!